Is Taylor Swift ‘The Ethical Billionaire’?

Is there such a thing as an ethical billionaire? And if there is, who meets the requirements? For a lot of people, Taylor Swift springs to mind. Her net worth of 2.4 billion dollars is something to behold, and her PR team works continuously to shape positive messaging around it. Splashy headlines celebrating $100,000 bonuses to her truck drivers and generous donations to local food banks along the Eras Tour route create an image of philanthropy and morality that few peers in her tax bracket can cultivate. Yet, there is more nuance beneath the surface. For example, the aforementioned bonuses. Each $100,000 gift is about 0.005% of her wealth. While undoubtedly life-changing for the recipients, critics question whether Swift could be a better example. 

So, is it the system that is broken or the person? Courtney Martin, an American feminist, author, speaker and social and political activist thinks it’s the system. When asked about whether the term ‘ethical billionaire’ was an oxymoron she stated that “I think the person, themselves, can strive towards being ethical. It is the system that is unethical. And in fact, I don’t think an ethical person exists, period. We all have hypocrisy within our daily lives no matter how much we try to escape it because we are a part of these huge systems and cultures that implicate us.” 

Something else to think about is the way Swift gained her immense wealth. Unlike the typical ruthless business practices of people like Jeff Bezos or Elon Musk, Swift amassed her wealth through creativity and songwriting, doing so in a male-dominated field. “I don’t ‘give her a pass’ but I do have more respect for the ways in which Taylor Swift made her wealth as I know it involved fighting back against sexism and exploitation in the industry,” Martin said. 

Additionally, there is much to be said about Swift’s political impact. Her fanbase contains hundreds of millions of people, enough to be  considered a significant voting bloc according to Carter Sherman of The Guardian. Newsweek polling published just before the 2024 election found that 18 percent of voters said they were “more likely” or “significantly more likely” to vote for a candidate endorsed by Swift. And that’s just the people that were willing to admit it. 

The sheer magnitude of her fame heavily distinguishes her from other artists in terms of political leverage, but opens her up to considerably more criticism. An Instagram post published amid the primaries of the 2024 election urged voters to “Vote the people who most represent YOU into power,” which, however neutral, provoked responses from right-wingers that her entire 18-year career must have been socially engineered. Shockingly one in five Americans believe this theory. She is not immune to commentary from the left side, either. Especially following her connection to Kansas City Chiefs player Travis Kelce, more and more theorists have been overly speculatory of the people Swift talks to, the places she goes and even the clothing she wears, all with the conclusion that the historically left-wing singer is an undercover MAGA supporter.

Laurel Elder, Associate Professor of Political Science at Hartwick College conducted a study entitled “Mirrorball Politics” about how the singer reflects America’s partisan and gender divides. One of her conclusions was that Swift is a mirror reflecting deep divisions in American society. “We have known for some time that Americans are deeply divided politically. But increasingly, those divisions are spilling over into almost every aspect of our lives, including where we live, what we watch, what we buy, and even what music we enjoy,” Elder said. “Democracy depends on our ability to disagree, compromise, and recognize the legitimacy of people who hold different views. If we lose the cultural spaces where we can connect across political differences, those democratic habits become much harder to sustain.”

Swift’s recently nonpartisan standpoint is logical, but a little depressing. Elder described how “powerful women face an additional layer of scrutiny. Their ambition, independence, and success can provoke resentment in ways that men’s success often does not.” The memory of the Dixie Chicks scandal of 2003, where an outspoken critique of George W. Bush derailed their country music career, remains a cautionary tale. 

Nevertheless, should there not be a point where an artist becomes too influential to silence? Other contemporary pop stars, such as Olivia Rodrigo, have used their platforms for far more impactful messaging. Rodrigo’s recent Daisy Chain Fields Music Festival and release of the politically-loaded song “Serena Joy” are some examples that come to mind. Even as anti-abortion protesters gathered outside the festival gates, she was still standing up for what she believed in and using her vast wealth (though not as vast as Swift’s) for societal benefit. 

Likewise, the late Dolly Parton, a singer-songwriter and actress, held a career very similar to Swift’s with one key difference: she never allowed herself to become a billionaire. Her 50% stake in the theme park Dollywood and many investments gave her a baseline net worth of about $500 million dollars, but she always found new ways to spend her money, such as building the Imagination Library, paying for every Dollywood employee to go to college and instituting a buddy program in her hometown which paired students up and promised each $500 if they both went to college. Enrollment rates skyrocketed from 64% to 94%. 

So, I don’t necessarily blame Swift. It’s the industry, not her. But in the end, I sang every word of Rodrigo’s new album at the Unraveled Tour, and wouldn’t be able to say the same about my participation in the Eras Tour. Scrutiny as a powerful woman is hard to deal with. But shouldn’t Swift, as well as every other billionaire, use her resources to make a difference?

Written by Ruby Lerman

Graphic by Oviyaa Ramesh

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.